Fairy Party Bag Fillers — Ideas for Every Budget
Fairy parties are one of the most popular children's party themes in the UK — and one of the best themes for party bag fillers too. The aesthetic lends itself perfectly to pretty, nature-inspired items that feel magical without being plastic tat. This guide covers the best fairy party bag fillers at every price point, from 50p treats to slightly bigger finds that will genuinely delight.
What Makes a Good Fairy Party Bag Filler?
The best fairy party bag fillers feel like they belong in an enchanted world. Think flowers, butterflies, nature, sparkle — but not the kind of sparkle that ends up as microplastic glitter on every surface in the house. The sweet spot is items that look magical, are durable enough to actually use, and don't cost a fortune when you're buying for ten or fifteen children.
Eco-friendly options work particularly well for a fairy theme because nature IS the theme. Flower seeds, wooden pencils, butterfly tattoos — these aren't a compromise, they're exactly right for the aesthetic.
Fairy Party Bag Fillers from 50p
Small fillers are perfect for padding out bags or as the main prize in an egg-and-spoon or fairy treasure hunt. Here are the best options at under £2:
Bunny Eraser — 50p
A shaped eraser feels like a proper little gift, not just filler. Works for younger children (3–6) who still find a novelty eraser genuinely exciting.
Butterfly Temporary Tattoos — £1.95
Two sheets of Floral Flutter Butterfly Tattoos — watercolour-style butterfly and flower designs. Perfect for a fairy theme, loved by ages 4–9, and plastic-free. One of the most popular fillers in the shop for a reason.
Nature Loving Flower Seeds — £1.95
Wildflower seeds in a beautifully illustrated packet feel like something a fairy might actually give you. Eco credentials are strong — biodegradable packaging, grows real flowers. Children (and parents) genuinely love receiving these.
Fairy Party Bag Fillers — £2 to £4
This mid-range is where you get items that feel more like a real gift. Ideal as the main filler if you're keeping bags simple with one or two items rather than six.
Garden Fairies Pencil Tube — £2.95
Twelve pencils in a reusable tube decorated with garden fairies. The Garden Fairies Pencil Tube is practical (children actually use pencils), eco-friendly, and feels considered rather than thrown in. Ages 4+.
ReCycleMe Mini Craft Kit — £3.50
A ReCycleMe Mini Craft Kit is the filler that keeps on giving — children make something from recycled cardboard, so it doubles as an activity. The woodland/nature feel fits a fairy theme well. Ages 5+.
Floral Party Crown — £3.00 each (sold as 6pk)
Floral Party Crowns by Meri Meri — if you want one standout filler that doubles as a party activity (wearing them during the party) and a take-home gift, these are it. Flower-covered paper crowns that feel genuinely magical. Ages 3–8.
What to Put in Fairy Party Bags — Full List by Age
Ages 3–5
- Butterfly tattoos — easy to apply with adult help, immediate joy
- Flower seeds — simple, pretty, parents appreciate the eco angle
- Floral party crown — wearable during the party and taken home
- Small eraser or pencil as a filler
Ages 5–8
- Garden Fairies pencil tube — practical and on-theme
- Butterfly tattoos — still loved at this age
- ReCycleMe craft kit — old enough to do most of it independently
- Flower seeds — especially good if they have a garden or window box
Ages 8–10
- ReCycleMe craft kit — the STEAM angle appeals to older children
- Butterfly tattoos (2 sheets) — still popular, especially the watercolour style
- Garden Fairies pencil tube — useful for school
Eco Fairy Party Bag Fillers
If you're hosting an eco-friendly fairy party, all of the fillers above are plastic-free — but here's the case for each:
- Flower seeds — FSC paper packaging, genuinely grows something. Zero plastic.
- Butterfly tattoos — paper-backed, no plastic wrapper. Biodegradable.
- Garden Fairies pencil tube — reusable tube, no single-use plastic.
- ReCycleMe craft kit — made from recycled cardboard and materials. The brand's entire purpose is eco.
- Floral party crowns — paper and card construction. No plastic.
See our full range of eco party bag fillers and eco party supplies for more plastic-free ideas.
How Many Fillers Do You Need?
For a fairy party bag, 3–5 items typically works well. A rough guide:
- Budget £3–4 per child: Butterfly tattoos + flower seeds + one small item
- Budget £5–6 per child: Garden Fairies pencil tube + butterfly tattoos + flower seeds
- Budget £7–8 per child: Floral party crown + ReCycleMe craft kit + flower seeds
All of the above are available from The Party Pirate's party bag fillers collection with UK delivery.
Fairy Party Bag Ideas — The Bag Itself
For a fairy party, consider a plain kraft paper bag (you can decorate with stickers or stamps) or a clear cello bag tied with ribbon so children can see what's inside. Both options are plastic-free and in keeping with a nature-inspired theme. See our fairy party supplies for the full range of fairy party products.
Frequently Asked Questions
What do you put in fairy party bags?
The best fairy party bag fillers are nature-inspired and magical in feel: butterfly temporary tattoos, wildflower seeds, floral pencil tubes, mini craft kits and paper flower crowns. These work for ages 3–10 and are all available plastic-free.
What are good eco fairy party bag fillers?
Wildflower seeds, butterfly tattoos (paper-backed), Garden Fairies pencil tubes, ReCycleMe craft kits and Meri Meri floral party crowns are all plastic-free and fit perfectly with a fairy theme. None involve single-use plastic.
How much should I spend on fairy party bag fillers?
A good fairy party bag with 3–4 fillers costs between £3 and £8 per child. Butterfly tattoos (£1.95) and flower seeds (£1.95) together make an excellent low-cost bag. Adding a Garden Fairies pencil tube (£2.95) takes it to around £6 per child for a bag that feels genuinely generous.
What age is a fairy party for?
Fairy parties work best for ages 3–8, with ages 4–7 being the sweet spot. Younger children love the magic and sparkle; older children in this range enjoy more craft and activity-based elements. The fillers above are suitable across this range.
Are there fairy party bag fillers that aren't plastic?
Yes — all of the fillers featured in this guide are plastic-free. Butterfly tattoos, wildflower seeds, pencil tubes, ReCycleMe craft kits and paper crowns are all made without single-use plastic and are available from The Party Pirate with UK delivery.